Crash on opening a gui SMP 1.4.5

Issue #79 resolved
Former user created an issue

When I open any gui game crashes.

---- Minecraft Crash Report ---- // Oh - I know what I did wrong!

Time: 12/5/12 2:59 PM Description: Unexpected error

java.lang.NoClassDefFoundError: codechicken/nei/forge/GuiContainerManager at auy.a(GuiContainer.java:64) at net.minecraft.client.Minecraft.a(Minecraft.java:665) at net.minecraft.client.Minecraft.l(Minecraft.java:1757) at net.minecraft.client.Minecraft.J(Minecraft.java:858) at net.minecraft.client.Minecraft.run(Minecraft.java:783) at java.lang.Thread.run(Unknown Source) Caused by: java.lang.ClassNotFoundException: codechicken.nei.forge.GuiContainerManager at cpw.mods.fml.relauncher.RelaunchClassLoader.findClass(RelaunchClassLoader.java:141) at java.lang.ClassLoader.loadClass(Unknown Source) at java.lang.ClassLoader.loadClass(Unknown Source) ... 6 more Caused by: java.lang.NullPointerException

A detailed walkthrough of the error, its code path and all known details is as follows:

-- Head -- Stacktrace: at auy.a(GuiContainer.java:64) at net.minecraft.client.Minecraft.a(Minecraft.java:665)

-- Affected level -- Details: Level name: MpServer All players: 1 total; [ayk['g1eagle'/34380, l='MpServer', x=263.34, y=70.62, z=106.72]] Chunk stats: MultiplayerChunkCache: 441 Level seed: 0 Level generator: ID 00 - default, ver 1. Features enabled: false Level generator options: Level spawn location: World: (168,64,252), Chunk: (at 8,4,12 in 10,15; contains blocks 160,0,240 to 175,255,255), Region: (0,0; contains chunks 0,0 to 31,31, blocks 0,0,0 to 511,255,511) Level time: 25513969 game time, 30810865 day time Level dimension: 0 Level storage version: 0x00000 - Unknown? Level weather: Rain time: 0 (now: false), thunder time: 0 (now: false) Level game mode: Game mode: survival (ID 0). Hardcore: false. Cheats: false Forced entities: 171 total; [oy['Chicken'/1, l='MpServer', x=273.56, y=62.39, z=118.16], ayk['g1eagle'/34380, l='MpServer', x=263.34, y=70.62, z=106.72], EntityBlock['unknown'/2, l='MpServer', x=269.50, y=64.45, z=95.45], EntityBlock['unknown'/3, l='MpServer', x=269.45, y=64.50, z=95.45], EntityBlock['unknown'/4, l='MpServer', x=269.50, y=71.45, z=95.45], EntityBlock['unknown'/5, l='MpServer', x=310.45, y=64.50, z=95.45], EntityBlock['unknown'/6, l='MpServer', x=269.50, y=64.45, z=99.45], EntityBlock['unknown'/7, l='MpServer', x=269.45, y=64.50, z=99.45], EntityBlock['unknown'/8, l='MpServer', x=310.45, y=64.50, z=99.45], EntityBlock['unknown'/9, l='MpServer', x=269.50, y=71.45, z=99.45], EntityBlock['unknown'/10, l='MpServer', x=269.45, y=64.45, z=95.50], EntityBlock['unknown'/11, l='MpServer', x=310.45, y=64.45, z=95.50], EntityBlock['unknown'/12, l='MpServer', x=269.45, y=71.45, z=95.50], EntityBlock['unknown'/13, l='MpServer', x=310.45, y=71.45, z=95.50], EntityBlock['unknown'/14, l='MpServer', x=279.50, y=56.45, z=118.45], EntityBlock['unknown'/15, l='MpServer', x=279.45, y=56.50, z=118.45], EntityBlock['unknown'/17, l='MpServer', x=289.45, y=56.50, z=118.45], EntityBlock['unknown'/16, l='MpServer', x=279.50, y=60.45, z=118.45], EntityBlock['unknown'/19, l='MpServer', x=279.45, y=56.50, z=128.45], EntityBlock['unknown'/18, l='MpServer', x=279.50, y=56.45, z=128.45], EntityBlock['unknown'/21, l='MpServer', x=279.50, y=60.45, z=128.45], qr['Zombie'/33338, l='MpServer', x=238.94, y=68.00, z=139.69], EntityBlock['unknown'/20, l='MpServer', x=289.45, y=56.50, z=128.45], EntityBlock['unknown'/23, l='MpServer', x=289.45, y=56.45, z=118.50], qn['Skeleton'/33336, l='MpServer', x=239.50, y=67.00, z=131.50], EntityBlock['unknown'/22, l='MpServer', x=279.45, y=56.45, z=118.50], EntityBlock['unknown'/25, l='MpServer', x=289.45, y=60.45, z=118.50], qn['Skeleton'/33335, l='MpServer', x=238.50, y=67.00, z=132.50], EntityBlock['unknown'/24, l='MpServer', x=279.45, y=60.45, z=118.50], px['item.item.string'/34325, l='MpServer', x=273.16, y=45.13, z=106.31], qc['Creeper'/34430, l='MpServer', x=185.50, y=74.00, z=88.50], px['item.item.egg'/34353, l='MpServer', x=276.38, y=62.13, z=120.88], oz['Cow'/29433, l='MpServer', x=281.09, y=64.00, z=90.97], qn['Skeleton'/34159, l='MpServer', x=278.50, y=64.00, z=140.50], oz['Cow'/29666, l='MpServer', x=286.81, y=64.00, z=83.97], px['item.tile.sapling.oak'/8312, l='MpServer', x=221.88, y=82.13, z=144.03], EntityBlock['unknown'/78, l='MpServer', x=273.50, y=64.45, z=143.45], EntityBlock['unknown'/79, l='MpServer', x=273.45, y=64.50, z=143.45], EntityBlock['unknown'/85, l='MpServer', x=273.50, y=69.45, z=147.45], EntityBlock['unknown'/84, l='MpServer', x=284.45, y=64.50, z=147.45], EntityBlock['unknown'/87, l='MpServer', x=284.45, y=64.45, z=143.50], EntityBlock['unknown'/86, l='MpServer', x=273.45, y=64.45, z=143.50], EntityBlock['unknown'/81, l='MpServer', x=284.45, y=64.50, z=143.45], qp['Spider'/33645, l='MpServer', x=242.41, y=67.00, z=112.13], EntityBlock['unknown'/80, l='MpServer', x=273.50, y=69.45, z=143.45], qp['Spider'/33646, l='MpServer', x=257.44, y=66.00, z=100.28], px['item.item.egg'/34353, l='MpServer', x=276.38, y=62.13, z=120.88], EntityBlock['unknown'/83, l='MpServer', x=273.45, y=64.50, z=147.45], qp['Spider'/33647, l='MpServer', x=261.28, y=69.00, z=107.34], EntityBlock['unknown'/82, l='MpServer', x=273.50, y=64.45, z=147.45], px['item.tile.sapling.oak'/6159, l='MpServer', x=225.09, y=79.13, z=151.88], EntityBlock['unknown'/89, l='MpServer', x=284.45, y=69.45, z=143.50], ow['Bat'/33820, l='MpServer', x=227.25, y=40.10, z=187.16], EntityBlock['unknown'/88, l='MpServer', x=273.45, y=69.45, z=143.50], oz['Cow'/34308, l='MpServer', x=310.63, y=64.00, z=80.53], pe['Sheep'/102, l='MpServer', x=227.50, y=68.00, z=155.50], pe['Sheep'/103, l='MpServer', x=214.13, y=72.00, z=150.13], oz['Cow'/34309, l='MpServer', x=305.44, y=64.00, z=93.56], oz['Cow'/34310, l='MpServer', x=304.13, y=64.00, z=80.03], pe['Sheep'/101, l='MpServer', x=228.53, y=74.00, z=142.78], oz['Cow'/34311, l='MpServer', x=310.41, y=64.00, z=92.66], px['item.tile.sapling.oak'/6151, l='MpServer', x=223.13, y=82.13, z=144.88], oz['Cow'/34304, l='MpServer', x=309.47, y=64.00, z=79.39], px['item.tile.sapling.oak'/6218, l='MpServer', x=222.88, y=80.13, z=152.66], pd['Pig'/34305, l='MpServer', x=307.19, y=64.00, z=78.13], qr['Zombie'/34306, l='MpServer', x=315.50, y=64.00, z=76.50], px['item.tile.sapling.oak'/8312, l='MpServer', x=221.88, y=82.13, z=144.03], oz['Cow'/34307, l='MpServer', x=304.09, y=64.00, z=78.09], pe['Sheep'/34316, l='MpServer', x=238.50, y=66.00, z=88.56], pd['Pig'/34317, l='MpServer', x=228.56, y=66.00, z=106.47], qp['Spider'/34318, l='MpServer', x=237.84, y=67.00, z=121.97], qr['Zombie'/34319, l='MpServer', x=235.88, y=67.00, z=121.69], oz['Cow'/34312, l='MpServer', x=310.34, y=64.00, z=86.75], qp['Spider'/34313, l='MpServer', x=317.16, y=67.00, z=104.51], pe['Sheep'/34314, l='MpServer', x=233.69, y=66.00, z=94.03], pe['Sheep'/104, l='MpServer', x=224.50, y=68.00, z=157.50], pe['Sheep'/105, l='MpServer', x=224.50, y=67.00, z=161.50], pe['Sheep'/34315, l='MpServer', x=239.88, y=66.00, z=81.56], px['item.item.string'/34325, l='MpServer', x=273.16, y=45.13, z=106.31], qr['Zombie'/34321, l='MpServer', x=247.74, y=65.00, z=76.77], qn['Skeleton'/34320, l='MpServer', x=226.03, y=67.00, z=123.56], EntityBlock['unknown'/122, l='MpServer', x=255.25, y=63.00, z=101.25], EntityBlock['unknown'/121, l='MpServer', x=255.25, y=63.00, z=105.25], EntityBlock['unknown'/120, l='MpServer', x=251.25, y=63.00, z=104.25], qp['Spider'/34536, l='MpServer', x=340.00, y=65.00, z=27.66], pe['Sheep'/34541, l='MpServer', x=337.58, y=75.00, z=120.66], px['item.tile.flower'/34436, l='MpServer', x=200.22, y=73.13, z=44.00], pe['Sheep'/34531, l='MpServer', x=328.97, y=70.00, z=174.13], oz['Cow'/129, l='MpServer', x=286.81, y=64.00, z=82.72], pe['Sheep'/34530, l='MpServer', x=321.09, y=68.00, z=170.03], qn['Skeleton'/34529, l='MpServer', x=326.41, y=63.00, z=50.97], qn['Skeleton'/34528, l='MpServer', x=323.50, y=63.00, z=53.50], qn['Skeleton'/34261, l='MpServer', x=252.50, y=68.00, z=140.50], oz['Cow'/132, l='MpServer', x=287.22, y=64.00, z=90.78], pe['Sheep'/34533, l='MpServer', x=320.03, y=69.00, z=179.06], qc['Creeper'/34532, l='MpServer', x=328.00, y=70.00, z=177.53], px['item.tile.sapling.oak'/34490, l='MpServer', x=248.13, y=77.13, z=44.97], px['item.tile.sapling.oak'/34488, l='MpServer', x=253.94, y=75.13, z=46.13], qc['Creeper'/34247, l='MpServer', x=223.50, y=66.00, z=138.50], qc['Creeper'/34547, l='MpServer', x=336.50, y=72.00, z=174.50], oz['Cow'/34300, l='MpServer', x=297.50, y=68.00, z=63.63], oz['Cow'/34301, l='MpServer', x=296.97, y=68.00, z=64.88], pe['Sheep'/170, l='MpServer', x=299.88, y=63.00, z=121.09], qc['Creeper'/34302, l='MpServer', x=294.00, y=64.00, z=63.38], qc['Creeper'/34506, l='MpServer', x=291.50, y=63.00, z=43.50], oz['Cow'/34303, l='MpServer', x=308.50, y=64.00, z=77.09], qp['Spider'/34296, l='MpServer', x=295.88, y=62.00, z=47.22], oz['Cow'/34297, l='MpServer', x=289.59, y=68.00, z=60.91], qc['Creeper'/33205, l='MpServer', x=273.41, y=63.00, z=114.06], oz['Cow'/34298, l='MpServer', x=294.93, y=68.00, z=57.09], pe['Sheep'/172, l='MpServer', x=296.06, y=65.00, z=173.41], oz['Cow'/34299, l='MpServer', x=290.16, y=68.00, z=59.69], ow['Bat'/34497, l='MpServer', x=258.29, y=37.10, z=36.56], oz['Cow'/34292, l='MpServer', x=278.44, y=64.00, z=85.25], EntityCartBasic['entity.Railcraft.cart.basic.name'/34293, l='MpServer', x=283.50, y=63.85, z=59.50], oz['Cow'/34294, l='MpServer', x=278.63, y=64.00, z=57.47], qp['Spider'/34295, l='MpServer', x=293.00, y=63.00, z=47.22], qr['Zombie'/34500, l='MpServer', x=284.19, y=63.00, z=41.96], qr['Zombie'/34289, l='MpServer', x=292.50, y=25.00, z=87.06], oz['Cow'/34290, l='MpServer', x=294.50, y=64.00, z=85.53], oz['Cow'/34291, l='MpServer', x=287.50, y=64.00, z=77.53], qn['Skeleton'/34042, l='MpServer', x=303.06, y=68.00, z=170.53], qn['Skeleton'/34525, l='MpServer', x=326.75, y=63.00, z=37.84], qn['Skeleton'/34526, l='MpServer', x=335.50, y=63.00, z=46.50], px['item.tile.sapling.oak'/6151, l='MpServer', x=223.13, y=82.13, z=144.88], qn['Skeleton'/34527, l='MpServer', x=333.50, y=63.00, z=44.50], pe['Sheep'/34512, l='MpServer', x=304.28, y=63.00, z=158.47], qc['Creeper'/34513, l='MpServer', x=309.50, y=69.00, z=171.50], pe['Sheep'/34514, l='MpServer', x=319.38, y=69.00, z=182.24], pe['Sheep'/34515, l='MpServer', x=317.47, y=69.00, z=186.53], px['item.tile.sapling.oak'/6159, l='MpServer', x=225.09, y=79.13, z=151.88], qn['Skeleton'/34478, l='MpServer', x=238.34, y=67.00, z=72.84], qn['Skeleton'/34477, l='MpServer', x=229.47, y=67.00, z=72.06], pd['Pig'/34476, l='MpServer', x=229.50, y=70.00, z=77.22], qc['Creeper'/33780, l='MpServer', x=252.50, y=68.00, z=143.50], qc['Creeper'/34475, l='MpServer', x=235.31, y=48.00, z=71.03], qn['Skeleton'/34474, l='MpServer', x=232.50, y=48.00, z=75.50], qc['Creeper'/34473, l='MpServer', x=229.50, y=48.00, z=68.50], ow['Bat'/34472, l='MpServer', x=227.72, y=39.83, z=69.71], ow['Bat'/34471, l='MpServer', x=225.20, y=48.83, z=79.41], qr['Zombie'/34470, l='MpServer', x=226.50, y=70.00, z=44.50], qn['Skeleton'/33785, l='MpServer', x=250.50, y=68.00, z=146.50], ow['Bat'/34494, l='MpServer', x=247.23, y=24.60, z=45.21], ow['Bat'/34495, l='MpServer', x=244.19, y=28.76, z=49.57], px['item.tile.sapling.oak'/34490, l='MpServer', x=248.13, y=77.13, z=44.97], px['item.tile.sapling.oak'/34488, l='MpServer', x=253.94, y=75.13, z=46.13], qc['Creeper'/34445, l='MpServer', x=214.50, y=62.00, z=31.50], qc['Creeper'/34447, l='MpServer', x=208.78, y=63.00, z=40.09], qn['Skeleton'/34446, l='MpServer', x=217.50, y=25.00, z=32.50], qn['Skeleton'/34437, l='MpServer', x=195.50, y=73.00, z=84.50], qn['Skeleton'/34224, l='MpServer', x=205.50, y=69.00, z=170.50], px['item.tile.flower'/34436, l='MpServer', x=200.22, y=73.13, z=44.00], qp['Spider'/34438, l='MpServer', x=191.88, y=72.00, z=78.28], qc['Creeper'/34460, l='MpServer', x=212.50, y=70.00, z=85.50], pe['Sheep'/34461, l='MpServer', x=223.94, y=70.00, z=85.06], ow['Bat'/34462, l='MpServer', x=214.36, y=40.98, z=98.39], qn['Skeleton'/33729, l='MpServer', x=290.50, y=68.00, z=149.50], pd['Pig'/34463, l='MpServer', x=215.88, y=68.00, z=99.34], ow['Bat'/34456, l='MpServer', x=211.59, y=42.23, z=99.67], ow['Bat'/34457, l='MpServer', x=235.39, y=41.06, z=71.45], pd['Pig'/34458, l='MpServer', x=221.50, y=71.00, z=84.31], qc['Creeper'/34459, l='MpServer', x=212.50, y=70.00, z=83.50], qc['Creeper'/34453, l='MpServer', x=210.50, y=30.00, z=66.50], qc['Creeper'/34454, l='MpServer', x=216.50, y=72.00, z=77.50], qn['Skeleton'/34455, l='MpServer', x=214.50, y=72.00, z=75.50], qc['Creeper'/34448, l='MpServer', x=211.66, y=62.00, z=29.82], qp['Spider'/33018, l='MpServer', x=230.91, y=66.00, z=135.38], ow['Bat'/34449, l='MpServer', x=215.75, y=65.10, z=32.53], qc['Creeper'/34450, l='MpServer', x=208.78, y=64.00, z=43.09], qc['Creeper'/34451, l='MpServer', x=221.59, y=71.00, z=43.91], px['item.tile.sapling.oak'/6218, l='MpServer', x=222.88, y=80.13, z=152.66]] Retry entities: 0 total; [] Stacktrace: at ayh.a(WorldClient.java:425) at net.minecraft.client.Minecraft.b(Minecraft.java:2385) at net.minecraft.client.Minecraft.run(Minecraft.java:806) at java.lang.Thread.run(Unknown Source)

-- System Details -- Details: Minecraft Version: 1.4.5 Operating System: Windows 7 (amd64) version 6.1 Java Version: 1.7.0_09, Oracle Corporation Java VM Version: Java HotSpot(TM) 64-Bit Server VM (mixed mode), Oracle Corporation Memory: 1703009528 bytes (1624 MB) / 2009792512 bytes (1916 MB) up to 2009792512 bytes (1916 MB) JVM Flags: 2 total; -Xms2000m -Xmx2000m AABB Pool Size: 28547 (1598632 bytes; 1 MB) allocated, 2 (112 bytes; 0 MB) used Suspicious classes: FML and Forge are installed IntCache: cache: 0, tcache: 0, allocated: 3, tallocated: 63 FML: MCP v7.23 FML v4.5.11.470 Minecraft Forge 6.4.1.413 33 mods loaded, 33 mods active mcp [Minecraft Coder Pack] (minecraft.jar) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available FML [Forge Mod Loader] (coremods) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available Forge [Minecraft Forge] (coremods) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available ExtraBees [Extra Bees] (extrabees-1.4.1.19-dev-build.zip) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available BinnieCore [Binnie Core] (extrabees-1.4.1.19-dev-build.zip) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available Forestry [Forestry for Minecraft] (forestry-A-1.6.2.3.jar) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available EE3 [Equivalent Exchange 3] (ee3-universal-pre1d.jar) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available ImmibisCore [Immibis Core] (immibis-core_51.0.3_for_1.4.5.jar) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available AdvancedRepulsionSystems [Advanced Repulsion Systems] (adv-repulsion-systems_51.0.1_for_1.4.5.jar) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available IC2 [IndustrialCraft 2] (industrialcraft-2_1.109.113-lf.jar) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available BuildCraft|Core [BuildCraft] (buildcraft-A-3.2.0.jar) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available BuildCraft|Builders [BC Builders] (buildcraft-A-3.2.0.jar) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available BuildCraft|Energy [BC Energy] (buildcraft-A-3.2.0.jar) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available BuildCraft|Factory [BC Factory] (buildcraft-A-3.2.0.jar) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available BuildCraft|Transport [BC Transport] (buildcraft-A-3.2.0.jar) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available BuildCraft|Silicon [BC Silicon] (buildcraft-A-3.2.0.jar) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available ComputerCraft [ComputerCraft] (ComputerCraft1.47.zip) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available CCTurtle [ComputerCraft Turtles] (ComputerCraft1.47.zip) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available ASTU [Aperture Science Turtle Upgrades] (ASTU_16_beta3.zip) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available mod_cjb_main [mod_cjb_main] (CJB_MAIN.zip) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available mod_cjb_chat [mod_cjb_chat] (CJB_CHAT.zip) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available mod_cjb_cheats [mod_cjb_cheats] (CJB_CHEATS.zip) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available mod_cjb_itemspawner [mod_cjb_itemspawner] (CJB_ITEMSPAWNER.zip) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available mod_cjb_measure [mod_cjb_measure] (CJB_MEASURES.zip) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available mod_cjb_minimap [mod_cjb_minimap] (CJB_MINIMAP.zip) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available mod_cjb_mobfilter [mod_cjb_mobfilter] (CJB_MOBFILTER.zip) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available mod_cjb_moreinfo [mod_cjb_moreinfo] (CJB_MOREINFO.zip) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available mod_cjb_teleport [mod_cjb_teleport] (CJB_TELEPORT.zip) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available mod_cjb_x_ray [mod_cjb_x_ray] (CJB_XRAY.zip) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available Mystcraft [Mystcraft] (mystcraft-uni-1.4.4-0.9.4.05.zip) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available PowerConverters [Power Converters] (PowerConverters_1.4.4.zip) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available Railcraft [Railcraft] (Railcraft_1.4.5b-6.9.2.0.zip) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available weaponmod [Balkon's WeaponMod] (Weaponmod.zip) Unloaded->Constructed->Pre-initialized->Initialized->Post-initialized->Available LWJGL: 2.4.2 OpenGL: Intel(R) HD Graphics Family GL version 3.1.0 - Build 8.15.10.2509, Intel Is Modded: Definitely; Client brand changed to 'forge,fml' Type: Client (map_client.txt) Texture Pack: Default Profiler Position: N/A (disabled) Vec3 Pool Size: 2769 (155064 bytes; 0 MB) allocated, 14 (784 bytes; 0 MB) used

Comments (3)

  1. Log in to comment