Wiki

Clone wiki

ekyc-ida / Minutes / eKYC-IDA_Meeting_Notes_2023-04-28

Attendees

  • Mark Haines
  • Kasuke Kawai
  • Takahiko Kawasaki
  • Dimo Postnikov
  • Daniel Fett
  • Joseph Heenan
  • Hodari McClain

Brief review of external Orgs & Events

  • OIDF Workshop 17 April

    • MS (Redmond?) Campus
    • Thorsten presented, Mark had unfortunate airport delay
    • Hodari attended virtually.
  • IIW 18-20 April

    • Justin Richer attended
    • Vectors of trust, and NIST stuff
  • OIDF Workshop 9 May 0830-1200 Berlin
  • EIC 2023 9-12 May Berlin

Main Agenda Items

  • Push OIDC4IDA to final is on!
  • Remaining move to final dependencies:

    • Address any last items for improvement (outstanding PRs and Issues)
    • Last call email to WG mailing list
    • Address any feedback
    • Check referenced specs hav correct dates
    • Update copyright date
    • Remote document history appendix
    • Publish with new version number and date
  • Feedback

    • Not getting as much feedback as we need to push through the process
    • Please take a look at PRs—comments or concerns are welcome
  • Housekeeping

    • Couple of PRs/Issues to close out
    • JWT claims registry stuff removed

Review PRs

  • Identity Assurance
    • New
    • Close
      • PR #157 - Some OP metadata needs to be optional
        • Discussed and Dima is comfortable with it
        • Need additional reviewer/approver
        • Merged on 3 May 2023 and Resolves related Issue#1357
    • Review
      • PR #158 - updated text in txn claim section
        • On IDA spec, couple of PRs open - 158 clarify normative status of this element
        • Not clear whether required or optional, SHOULD = RECOMMENDED
        • Not Merged
  • Authority: None

Review Issues

  • Identity Assurance

    • New
      • Issue #1360: Add text about conformance testing - Joseph
        • Recommended that we add text similar to FAPI1 spec so implementers run conformance testing
        • Michael will raise Issue, probably can’t do PR
        • Not Resolved
    • Close
    • Review

      • Issue #1339: Create profiles of the OIDC4IDA spec - Mark & Dima

        • Not a dependency or IDA spec as it stands
        • Don’t want to delay the work of moving IDA to final
        • Not Resolved
      • Issue #1359: Claims under evidence - Mark

        • Potential for conflict with personal_number claims—are not unique
          • Exists under evidence document, electronic records, and vouch types
        • 3 Options - 1. Do nothing, 2. Add claims, retain personal_number 3. Add claims, deprecate personal_number
        • Mark to write down what potential ways forward are and relative merits ahead of next WG
        • Not Resolved
      • Issue #1281: Add verified person_numbers to Additional Claims about End-Users - Mark

        • Soliciting community feedback, Mark to speak to Mike Jones
        • Not Resolved
  • Advanced Syntax for Claims

    • Issue #1276: [SAO] Output claim set varies depending on evaluation order - Daniel
      • Not Resolved
    • Issue #1320: Claim Controls - Daniel
      • Not Resolved
  • Authority

    • No Update

Other/Recognition

  • Two orgs got IDA approval
  • Will add to OIDF Workshop

  • “Minna no Ginko” Bank has launched FAPI-certified OpenID Provider that has associated /userInfo endpoint

    • Mitsumi Primary Life Insurance Company consuming
    • Minna Bank supports FAPI 1.0, want to support FAPI 2.0
    • https://www.minna-no-ginko.com

Updated