BirdBase/Avisys imports should use a complete Leeward Islands checklist on import, not Montserrat

Scythebill makes a number of compromises to reflect limitations in BirdBase/Avisys, assigning sightings to one location even though they might reflect multiple.

The problem with this is that Scythebill then just uses the checklist for that one location to resolve taxonomic conundrums, which is wrong! Scythebill should be using a merged checklist for all possible locations (to the extent that Scythebill has multiple checklists).

“Leeward Islands” sightings are all saved in Montserrat. You may need to move some to Antigua and Barbuda, St. Kitts and Nevis, or Anguilla. “New Guinea” sightings are all saved in Papua New Guinea; some may more properly belong to the Papua state of Indonesia. “Bismarcks” sightings are all saved to the state of West New Britain in Papua New Guinea; these could belong to East New Britain or New Ireland. “Java and Bali” sightings are added to the “Jawa” province of Indonesia. Bali sightings will need to be moved to Nusa Tenggara. “Timor” sightings are saved in the country of East Timor; some may belong to the Nusa Tenggara state of Indonesia. “Lesser Sundas” sightings are all assigned to Nusa Tenggara, though some of the islands in this chain - Wetar, in particular - should be in Maluku. Malaysian Borneo sightings are added to the Malaysian state of Sabah, though they might belong in Sarawak. “Yugoslavia” sightings will all be saved in Serbia. You may need to move sightings to Montenegro or Kosovo. “Palau” sightings include sightings from the Caroline Islands in Micronesia. “Saint Helena” sightings include sightings from the Ascension Islands. “Neotropical” sightings are added to South America, though they could be Central America. (Sightings ascribed to a country? Not a problem.)

Comments (1)