Issue #5084 wontfix

Sensible defaults for Pull Request configuration

Kevin Stanton
created an issue

Before the upgrade to the newer, sexier BitBucket, when creating a pull request it would select sensible defaults. For example, let's say we have:

MainRepo, with 2 branches: default, stage

then I fork MainRepo as MyMainFork.

I make changes in the default branch of MyMainFork, and push them to my fork on BitBucket.

At that point, I select "Pull Request" to issue one. In the old BitBucket, by default it selected the branch w/ changesets that were ahead of the common ancestor between MainRepo and MyMainFork, and it would choose the destination repository as MainRepo.

In the new BitBucket, it picks the default branch and MyMainFork as the defaults for the Pull Request destination. This doesn't make any sense!! Why would I issue a Pull Request from MyMainFork to MyMainFork?

I've done this by accident twice now, and was left wondering why nobody could see my Pull Request.

Comments (5)

  1. Marcus Bertrand staff

    The way it works is that we default as follows:

    The most recently updated branch in the current repository is selected by default and the default or master branch of the same repo is selected as the destination.

    If you are working in a fork, the usual workflow is that you'll be merging from your master/default into the fork. If the master/default is the last updated, we'll default from your master to the parent of the fork.

  2. Mike Macaulay

    Marcus,

    Is there any way to change these defaults? We're in the situation where we've gone so far away from our forked repo that our project is really stand-alone.

    Alternatively, since we're so far away from the original, is there a way to remove the relationship of our project to the forked project so that the pull request button won't default to the forked repo? I've tried looking at git remote but the forked repo is not in that list.

    Any help would be greatly appreciated!

  3. Log in to comment