Overlapping characters between footnote number with two digits and footnote text when using footmisc

Issue #154 resolved
Hugues de Lassus created an issue

Here's a MWE with LaTeX2e, classicthesis latest version, using footmisc. footmisc itself does not cause the problem.

\documentclass[final]{book}
\usepackage{classicthesis}
\begin{document}
\footnote{Footnote with one digit}
\footnote{Footnote with one digit}
\footnote{Footnote with one digit}
\footnote{Footnote with one digit}
\footnote{Footnote with one digit}
\footnote{Footnote with one digit}
\footnote{Footnote with one digit}
\footnote{Footnote with one digit}
\footnote{Footnote with one digit}
\footnote{Footnote with two digits} % "0" and "F" may overlap here.
\end{document}

The problem comes from the negative length set for \footnotemargin with the flushmargin option. The following patch fixes the problem.

--- classicthesis.sty.orig      2018-04-02 00:33:02.689565353 +0200
+++ classicthesis.sty   2018-04-02 00:33:14.857564987 +0200
@@ -594,11 +594,9 @@
     \deffootnote{0em}{0em}{\thefootnotemark\hspace*{.5em}}%
     \message{Using KOMA-command "deffootnote" for footnote setup}%
 \else
-    \PassOptionsToPackage{flushmargin}{footmisc}%
     \RequirePackage{footmisc}%
-    \setlength{\footnotemargin}{-.5em}%
-    \PackageWarningNoLine{classicthesis}{Using package "footmisc" with option %
-        "flushmargin" for footnote setup (not 100\% the same as with KOMA)}%
+    \PackageWarningNoLine{classicthesis}{Using package "footmisc" for %
+      footnote setup (not 100\% the same as with KOMA)}%
 \fi

 % ********************************************************************

Official response

  • André Miede repo owner

    Thank you for pointing to this problem and providing a solution. Changing to the marginal option is another possibility which is a bit closer to our KOMA-approach from its appearance.

    \PassOptionsToPackage{marginal}{footmisc}

    The fix will be in the next release.

Comments (2)

  1. André Miede repo owner

    Thank you for pointing to this problem and providing a solution. Changing to the marginal option is another possibility which is a bit closer to our KOMA-approach from its appearance.

    \PassOptionsToPackage{marginal}{footmisc}

    The fix will be in the next release.

  2. Log in to comment