Tikal extraction ignores -nocopy option with -seg option

Issue #571 resolved
Zsolt Nagy created an issue

When running tikal -x with the -seg option, the -nocopy option is ignored, and targets contain the source text.

Comments (3)

  1. Zsolt Nagy reporter

    Now I am not sure if it is an issue at all. I have created a script that removed all the contents of the target units, and now my CAT tool complains that xliff is not pretranslated (target slot missing). Can somebody explain me why segmented units have to be pretranslated?

  2. ysavourel

    The issue you reported (source text gets copied into target even if -nocopy is set) is a valid issue: By default the segmenter copies the source and, clearly, it should not if -nocopy is there. I'm fixing it right now.

    Now, the issue of the CAT tool not liking empty/absent targets is another issue. From an XLIFF viewpoint it is perfectly valid to have an XLIFF file with a source (segmented or not) with an empty target or no target. The CAT tool is apparently not supporting XLIFF very well.

  3. Log in to comment