Attendees

• Nat Sakimura
• Domingos Creado
• Mike Leszcz
• Tatsuo Kudo
• Joseph Heenan
• Bertrand
• Andrew Hughes
• Mark Haine
• Daniel Fett
• Takasaki Kawasaki

Brief review of external Orgs & Events

• Series of identity related events.
  • Authenticate in October in Seattle
  • IIW in November, also OIDF workshop prior to the IIW
  • IETF 114
  • FDX Meeting
  • Money 2020 in Las Vegas
  • Identity Week Singapore
  • ISO/TC 68 - natural person identifier standardization

PRs & Issues

• Review PRs

  • PR #114 – ISO references – Taka – 8601:2014 (withdrawn) or 8601-1:2019
    • We should refer to most recent one, 8601-2019.
    • Mark will write summary of discussion in the PR.
  • PR #116 – fix document structure – Daniel
    • No concern from attendees
    • merged
  • PR #117 – Clarifications in section 5.3 – Mark
    • No updates
  • PR #118 – Clarification of key retrieval - Daniel
    • To fix the word "claim source" in another PR.
  • PR #119 - Daniel
    • Raised during this meeting
    • Addressing on the issue #1254

• Review Issues

  • Currently tagged for ID4:
    • Issue #1309 – Is JSON Schema normative? - Mark
      • The easiest way to solve this one is to say it's not normative. But it make the conformance test difficult. - Mark
      • Do not recommend to make schema normative for long term. - Daniel
        • We can not distinguish between should and must in the schema
        • Most people will be working with the text, not the schema.
      • The draft is the prime definition. And the schema is also normative but if there's a discrepancy between schema and drafts, then the draft is the master and for a number of specified parts of the schema, they're not normative and effectively implementations of stuff that's not typically referenced in other specs. - Mark
    • Issue #1261 – JSON ‘null’ – Joseph
      • Mark, Torsten, Joseph, Brian had a conversation around this topic.
      • Not reached to conclusion and continue discussing in the ticket.
      • This issue is problematic for some of library implementations.
      • At least for there is no problem on Daniel's implementation.
    • Issue #1308 – essential claims handling – Joseph
      • Assigned to Daniel.
      • Daniel will create PR for this issue.
    • Issue #1287 – Broken reference in JSON Schema – Torsten?
    • Issue #1300 – Document History & Acknowledgements - Jules
    • Issue #1256 – Clarification about retrieving keys - Daniel
    • Issue #1306 – Identifier for UK DIATF - Adrian
    • Issue #1254 – clarification about optional sub-elements - Daniel