Attendees

• Bjorn Hjelm
• Dave Tonge
• Mark Haine
• Mike Leszcz
• Nat Sakimura
• Brian Campbell
• Dima Postnikov
• Don Thibeau
• Gail Hodges
• Joseph Heenan
• Kosuke Koiwai
• Naohiro Fujie
• Takahiko Koiwai
• Torsten Lodderstedt

Brief review of external Orgs & Events

• Identiverse
  • Mike organizing in person meeting at Identiverse

Main Agenda Items

• Proposal to get to Final this year:

Naohiro expressed concern about too short gap between the implementers draft 4 and the final.

• NOT DO in Implementer’s Draft 4
  • Anything in other drafts – ASC, Authority
  • Anything that could or should be done as an extra draft or profile
    • New end-user claims
    • Further enrichment to metadata
    • Richer error handling
    • Pending Verification
    • Pre-defined claims sets
  • Most of the JSON Schema issues (except Issue #1287)
  • Mapping to eIDAS
  • Issue #1283 – birth_date definition -> do in ASC
  • Issue #1292 - unique person identifiers -> other draft or profile
• DO in Implementer’s Draft 4
  • PR #112 - External attachment audience
  • PR #114 - ISO references
  • Issue #1300 – Document History & Acknowledgements
  • Issue #1256 – Clarification about retrieving keys
  • Issue #1255 – Section 5.3 clarifications
  • Issue #1306 – Identifier for UK DIATF
  • Issue #1254 –clarification about optional sub-elements
  • Issue #1247 – value/values
  • Issue #1287 – Broken reference in JSON Schema
• Decide whether to include in Implementer’s Draft 4
  • Issue #1261 – JSON ‘null’
    • Joseph proposed make essentially mandatory
    • Torsten's concern is backward compatibility
  • Statement that JSON Schema is normative or not
    • Mark raised this as #1309
    • Kosuke : Will there be any barriers to use JSON schema when we are sending the spec to other organization such as ISO?
    • Nat: If we want to finish the 1.0 quickly, it may be better to keep JSON Schema non-normative and wait for ver 1.1 or something to get it normative.

PRs & Issues

• Review PRs

  • PR #112 – External attachment token audience – Taka
    • Joseph has reviewed the PR
  • PR #114 – ISO references – Taka
    • Mark and Jules will review offline and no one expressed objection to merge this PR after their approval was made.
  • PR #115 – fix value/values – Daniel
    • Joseph and Taka approved the PR
  • PR #116 – fix document structure – Daniel
    • Joseph already approved this

• Review Issues

  • New
    • Issue #1307 – Section 7.6 html render – Mark
    • Issue #1308 – essential claims handling - Joseph